Jump to content

another bolting ethics question/topic


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 106
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

these are boulders with top rope anchors....why would you chop them? i'm sure you and your friends use stacks of humping pads for landings...this is no different than top roping...if the boulders do not have natural or gear anchors available on top than the bolts seem quite justified...i also would not claim to be responsible for fa's on boulders, i mean really...you have no idea who may have climbed those boulders before you, they make great perches for launching knapped projectiles into big game...get my drift...besides, in the northwest dirt comes back quite quickly..where i live they have written a guide book with names, fa's, etc about countless boulders that i had climbed on previous to their claims...i as they, was surely not the first, nevertheless like you they claim fa's and other such nonsense...like someone else said "don't use them"...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Does it give you wood to work yourself into such a state of high ethical dudgeon?

 

No, it doesnt not why do you think it does? The fact is this is mainly a bouldering area, there is one "roped" climb wich i put up using gear and 1 bolt. But for me, this

was the first time something i fa'd or what ever you want to call it had bolts added to it.

 

and after all whod place a rawl 5p and a fixe wedge for an anchor?

 

Am I missing something? What's wrong with that? We frequently mix up 1/2", 3/8", 5- piece, wedge, buttonheads, pins, zinc plated, stainless, etc. I see no problem with it as long as it's solid. It certainly doesn't guarantee they didn't know what they were doing.

 

Okay sure anything goes for wall anchors and stuff, one fatty and some button heads and or machine heads. But this is a top rope anchor drilled from a sitting on your ass stance. Why not just do it once, do it right? I guess in the long run it comes down to personal opinion, but i would never place 2 mismatched bolts for a top rope anchor. mabey im a perfectionist, or want things to match.

 

 

It certainly doesn't guarantee they didn't know what they were doing.

 

Nor does the fact that they cratered a hole.

 

Okay I guess you might have to see the holes and bolt placement, ya sure everyone craters a hole a little bit from time to time. But if I was drilling from a sitting on my ass stance i would try as hard as possible to make a perfect hole. one of the holes i found to be craterd so bad i probably wouldnt have put a bolt in it. they beat that wedge down in there so hard it mushroomed the tip, the rawl was barley tightend, obvious hammer marks all over around the bolts. So I seriously hope it wasnt someone with some bolting experince, because I would hate to get on one of their routes.

 

 

so mabey i didnt make my self clear enough at the begining, but i get the feeling everyone thinks im wrong here. anyways bigdrink.gif

Link to comment
Share on other sites

oh cappelini- IM SURE you know that i dont own a bouldering pad, i have one friend who i go there with that owns a single small one, and i could probably count the number of times on one hand ive botherd to use it(i consider my self and aid climber and say how i "hate" bouldering)... i never boulder(because im weak as shit) and i think pads are aid. the reason we belive we made some of the fas, are the same reasons why you would belive you climbed an roped fa. we had to cut the trails, spend hours and hours of cleaning, this is probably the mossiest place ive ever climbed. and it was only revealed recently due to logging. all the boulder have natural andchors and walk offs.

 

i just get the feeling from everyone that you think im a fucking moron. ive thought about all of this shit before, i know when and when not to claim and FA etc etc. i think every one is aussming way to much about me and this place i speak of. i am younger than most every one on this site, and mabey it shows but i like to try and stick to old school ethics, pads and bolts-in the wrong places to me are wrong. i recently just caved into using a power drill. find out more facts, before you try and make me look wrong and stupid.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

..i also would not claim to be responsible for fa's on boulders, i mean really...you have no idea who may have climbed those boulders before you, they make great perches for launching knapped projectiles into big game...get my drift...

 

I'm guessing they went the easiest way up the easy part of the bolder as opposed to the easiest way up the hardest part. sure they may have gone up some 5.8 jugs, but I'm guessing they did not go the inverted v4 route from the sit.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

..i also would not claim to be responsible for fa's on boulders, i mean really...you have no idea who may have climbed those boulders before you, they make great perches for launching knapped projectiles into big game...get my drift...

 

I'm guessing they went the easiest way up the easy part of the bolder as opposed to the easiest way up the hardest part. sure they may have gone up some 5.8 jugs, but I'm guessing they did not go the inverted v4 route from the sit.

 

yeah seriously, i cant imagine a hunter busting out v whatever the hell any of that means with his gun slung over his shoulder

Link to comment
Share on other sites

oh cappelini- IM SURE you know that i dont own a bouldering pad, i have one friend who i go there with that owns a single small one, and i could probably count the number of times on one hand ive botherd to use it(i consider my self and aid climber and say how i "hate" bouldering)... i never boulder(because im weak as shit) and i think pads are aid. the reason we belive we made some of the fas, are the same reasons why you would belive you climbed an roped fa. we had to cut the trails, spend hours and hours of cleaning, this is probably the mossiest place ive ever climbed. and it was only revealed recently due to logging. all the boulder have natural andchors and walk offs.

 

i just get the feeling from everyone that you think im a fucking moron. ive thought about all of this shit before, i know when and when not to claim and FA etc etc. i think every one is aussming way to much about me and this place i speak of. i am younger than most every one on this site, and mabey it shows but i like to try and stick to old school ethics, pads and bolts-in the wrong places to me are wrong. i recently just caved into using a power drill. find out more facts, before you try and make me look wrong and stupid.

 

Don't let the internet tough-guys get you down, Kid! wave.gif

Link to comment
Share on other sites

don't take it personal...this site is full of shit therefore we are....they're boulders..fairly insignificant summits..so woopy if there's bolts on top...for a 6 yr old those boulders are huge, let em top rope..it s not like someone grid bolted your bolder...around here people are downbolting faces that have already been climbed with ample traditional protection..bolts next to gear...i see it regularly..disgrace..if the place feels special to you and the bolts offend you...remove them..i would if i felt that way about your boulder field and wanted to waste my time roremoving bolts

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bolts and boulder problems cannot coexist.

 

And whoever said "clipstick" nice try but it's called a CHEATER STICK. Calling it a "clipstick" is like calling your period "A visit from Auntie".

 

I know Dru is baiting but I can't take it!!!! Muusstt Post...

 

Cheater Stick = stick used to clip fix aid gear out of reach thus "skipping" the hard aid.

 

Clip Stick = stick used to clip rope to first bolt where it's 1) needed because of bad landing 2) deemed to high/scary for climber*

 

* = debate can rage on this of course one man's death fall is another's runnout. There are places where the FA MEANT the bolt to be clipped though...

 

flame on

 

edit to add clips sticks are fine with me in sport areas but I'll laugh at you if you show up at the apron with a 20 foot pole

Edited by matt_m
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Getting a toprope through the opening moves = cheating.

 

Who gives a shit. I'm not going to risk breaking my feet/legs to be considered "not a cheater" by Dru.

 

Fuck that.

 

I used to take a Stick-clip/clip-stick to Smith when I used to climb there a lot. Lots of hard starts there with risk of groundfall.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Getting a toprope through the opening moves = cheating.

 

Who gives a shit. I'm not going to risk breaking my feet/legs to be considered "not a cheater" by Dru.

 

Fuck that.

 

I used to take a Stick-clip/clip-stick to Smith when I used to climb there a lot. Lots of hard starts there with risk of groundfall.

Climbing to enjoy yourself doesn't need to be defended.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hey if you "don't want to take a risk" why don't you stick to flower arranging and lawn bowling.

That's like saying you won't screw b/c it's no fun w/o a condom.

Let go--let other people enjoy climbing the way they want to. What difference does it make to you?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




×
×
  • Create New...