i agree with all of you, but guiding in a national forest (x38) is no longer legal (talk to your congressmen people!)
My group has already been to peshastin, vantage, mt erie, and tieton this season, index is our last stop. We may change this in the future. Spire rock is man made and not what we are about.
The crags we have visited are the only worthy crags for kids that are not in a nat'l forest or park and I would love to make index a worth while trip but want to do so without messing with the climbing community (aka me and all like minded people, i know i would be pissed if I stumbled into the lower town wall to see a group of kids hogging GNS).
I will probably go out to my private idaho or possibly k cliff.
any other ideas are welcome, keep them coming, but keep it index, i know the rest of the crags of washington.