leejams Posted July 22, 2003 Posted July 22, 2003 Wondering what everyone else uses and likes/dislikes. Also can't make up my mind to go with a bomber type bivvy sack, or a cheaper bivvy sack with tarp? Quote
Bronco Posted July 22, 2003 Posted July 22, 2003 I say go with a cheap/light bivi sack, if it's crappy out, you should be headed home. I have the MEC/Integral Designs South Col and it's a compromise between lightweight and storm worthy, I'd go even lighter next time. Quote
Greg_W Posted July 22, 2003 Posted July 22, 2003 Take into account that Bronco is Irish, and therefore cheap as a tin cup. I never go cheap on gear that my life may depend on. Â I, on the recommendation/endorsement of several friends, purchased an Integral Designs Unishelter. It's totally bomber, comfy, and has a great hoop system that gives you some headroom. I've used it on a bunch of different occasions and woken up to rain and been totally comfy. Quote
Rodchester Posted July 22, 2003 Posted July 22, 2003 As long as you plan on using it in good weather, more as a back-up in case you do hit bad weather, I would go light and simple. Â Why carry a three pound bivy sack with fancy poles and bells and whistles? My Bibler weighs a hair less than four pounds and sleeps two (One-door I-Tent). So unless its less than two pounds, it ain't worth taking a bivy. (For me anyway). Â Quote
erik Posted July 22, 2003 Posted July 22, 2003 they are all the same. go with cheap. dont get poles if you are alpine climbing with it. go as lite as possible. use the trap or the bivi, but not both, that is overkill. why bivi? Â Quote
leejams Posted July 22, 2003 Author Posted July 22, 2003 All good points, thanks for the input. Sounds like cheap and light are the way to go. Seem to never find any of em on sale though Quote
mattp Posted July 22, 2003 Posted July 22, 2003 I'm with the light and cheap school on this question. I don't think there are very many times when the heavier or more expensive one is going to keep you drier, and the fancier ones with tent poles start to weigh nearly as much as a small tent. Â Cheaper and lighter yet is to skip it altogether. For more than one person, the weight savings as compared to a light weight tent are not all that substantial -- especially when you look at everything else in your pack. If the weather is good, you don't need the bivvy sack and I don't know many people who would take just the bivvy sack when headed out in questionnable weather anyway. Lots of people swear by 'em, but I have never used a bivvy sack in thirty years' climbing. If the weather is fair, I just take a sleeping bag and maybe a headnet and plan to put my feet in a garbage bag or in my pack and pull on a raincoat if it rains. Quote
Dru Posted July 23, 2003 Posted July 23, 2003 find caves under boulders to sleep in. no need for sack. Quote
slothrop Posted July 23, 2003 Posted July 23, 2003 How waterproof are those space bags? I took one with me in case it rained last weekend and I needed to cover my down bag like mattp suggests, but I dunno if it would have just shredded quickly in the wind. Quote
Fence_Sitter Posted July 23, 2003 Posted July 23, 2003 i have a micro swift one man tent from walrus, and what i like is i can use any variation of things to keep me as protected as i want or to go lightwieght... i just take the tent as bug protectant (and a lil weather) at less than most (nearly all) bivies and i sometimes just take the cover and wrap myself around it... it was cheaper tahn any decent bivy bag i have seen adn kicks ass... fully guyed it is decently storng too... Quote
Coopah Posted July 23, 2003 Posted July 23, 2003 I use this one from MEC. http://www.mec.ca/Products/product_detail.jsp?FOLDER<>folder_id=589113&PRODUCT<>prd_id=118583&bmUID=1058925785683 Weighs about a pound... Quote
leejams Posted July 23, 2003 Author Posted July 23, 2003 mattp said: Lots of people swear by 'em, but I have never used a bivvy sack in thirty years' climbing. If the weather is fair, I just take a sleeping bag and maybe a headnet and plan to put my feet in a garbage bag or in my pack and pull on a raincoat if it rains. Â I was with that school of thought myself for many years (not 30 years though ) However, borrowed one awhile back from JoshK on a trip and became instantly convinced. A.) I sleep better alone. B.) it adds a bit of warmth to the lighter bag. C.) Last Friday night I just went with the sleeping bag aproach, woke up and in half sleep grabbed something on my face and a big ass slug Freakin gave me the willy's. Quote
Pencil_Pusher Posted July 23, 2003 Posted July 23, 2003 Become a human burrito by wrapping yourself up in a space blanket. Or... one bivy bag for two people Quote
HernyG Posted July 23, 2003 Posted July 23, 2003 (edited) Any comments on the REI (Capitalist Pig - see another thread) Minimalist Bivy? There is not much out there in the outdoorgearreview.com world about this cheap and light sack. Edited July 23, 2003 by HernyG Quote
minx Posted July 23, 2003 Posted July 23, 2003 cj001f said: Bibler Winter Bivy. Cheaper & Lighter. Â Â absolutely love mine. used it a bunch last year instead of taking a tent. super light and kept me dry in the middle of an unexpected downpour. Thought it was pricey at the time but well worth the $$$ Quote
Beck Posted July 25, 2003 Posted July 25, 2003 all you need is a tarp, you can wrap yourself up in it if you can't pitch it, use it like a blanket, but a 5x8 siltarp for one pitched low to ground is the way to go-packs up the size of a tennis ball! Â lightest, most breathable option, obviously not for Alaska summer trips but everything Cascade, THAT'S ALL YOU NEED- don't take anything more and you'll be okay... for two people a 10x12 is better. Â Learn how to pitch the darn thing, and get creative with how you pitch it, is my advice. bivies have a place, but not much, and tents have places but not many, and i'm just a dirtbag climber anyway who likes sleeping out with mother nature as the floor. Quote
mattp Posted July 25, 2003 Posted July 25, 2003 The tarp is a good option as long as you are going to spend the night at or below timberline. It's not so good above, though I have set them between boulders and stuff. Bring a headnet if you are tarp camping in the summer! Quote
leejams Posted July 25, 2003 Author Posted July 25, 2003 Beck said: all you need is a tarp, you can wrap yourself up in it if you can't pitch it, use it like a blanket, but a 5x8 siltarp for one pitched low to ground is the way to go-packs up the size of a tennis ball! Â That sounds good in weather like we are having now. However, with a down bag will that keep out the melting snow,bivvys sights with a small pond in them, slugs etc... I do like the siltarp though just wondering how many seasons you can go with that idea? Â Â Quote
chelle Posted July 25, 2003 Posted July 25, 2003 I have a Bibler bivy sack that is nice, but I get a bit claustrophobic in it if it is fully zipped up. It hasa hoop, but the bug net droops on my face. Â If you're trying to save money check with stores like second ascent about factory seconds. I got mine in Berkeley at a good discount just cause the fabric had a wrinkle in it that was considered a blemish. Saved about $70. Quote
mattp Posted July 25, 2003 Posted July 25, 2003 Lee- I have been using a tarp for years, and at all times of the year. The advantages of a tarp over a tent are actually INCREASED in bad weather or when snow camping. In these situations, there are no mosquito's to worry about, and you can set the tarp high or low or tip it one way or the other, depending on whether wind is blowing rain or snow underneath, whether you are doing a lot of cooking or whether there may be something to look at. The chief advantages are that you have much more room to hang out in for much less weigiht, you can lounge around in your sleeping bag while you cook, and you can see where you are instead of being walled off from the woods and mountains that you have come to enjoy. It takes a little more effort than just throwing up a tent, but I use a down bag with a normal shell (not goretex), and no bivvy bag, and not once in litterally hundreds of nights out under a tarp* have I gotten my bag seriously wet because I was using a tarp rather than a tent. In "weather like we are having now," I would leave even the tarp behind, but a tent might actually be better because of the mosquito control it offers. Â *As I posted above, you do have to camp at or below timberline, though. I DID get wet, though not dangerously so, on one occasion when trying to set a tarp on granite ledges above timberline in a snowstorm in the Sierra. Quote
chilly Posted July 25, 2003 Posted July 25, 2003 The Integral Designs sola is a great bivy that you can change in and is their version of Gore-Tex. It's about 3 lbs. Quote
mattp Posted July 25, 2003 Posted July 25, 2003 Why would you carry a three pound bivvy bag? Many small tents weigh less than four pounds! Quote
chilly Posted July 28, 2003 Posted July 28, 2003 It packs smaller and costs less than anything else comparible, like the Bibler I-tent, or the ID tent styled like the I-tent. Quote
mneagle Posted July 29, 2003 Posted July 29, 2003 I have a Wild Things bivi bag and I think it's great. The whole thing is made of sympatex so there's very little condensation. The mosquito netting is effective at keeping the bugs out and is large enough to allow for adequate ventilation as well. It weighs in at 15 ounces. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.