I don't know how you guys are really going to learn anything when you use such a caustic tone with each other. It will proabaly be a bit more productive if you guys starting using some modifiers: "what has worked for me...", " that's interesting, but in my experience...." Just a thought...
Kimmo, is it really worth your time to respond to every minute detail of every single post? Personally I enjoy your posts about training and your ideas about hard rock climbing, but remember you are posting to what is a mostly alpine based climbing message board that proabaly have a hard time understanding that for some, "hard" rock climbing, doesn't even begin until 5.13.
Personally, I very much beleive in periodization for what my goals in climbing are: free ascents of long, technical, traditional alpine rock climbs (Dragons of Eden, Vanishing Point, Thin Red Line, The Tempest, etc.).
I agree that if your main focus is single pitch sport, trad, or bouldering, you can improve simply by working your fingers, movements, and forearms, and that that improvement can come somewhat quickly and simply once one knows how to train for it. From there there is a wide range of skills to focus on as one moves across the wide spectrum of climbing styles, say from technical rock climber to mixed/iced alpininst, to full on slogger. Each type of climbing will improve with a different ratio of focused skill sets. Training for technical rock climbing is proabaly the simplest.
I've had a couple of good seasons in the last couple of years and have learned alot about training as it relates to my goals in climbing. Over the holiday break I should have time to post more about what I think works for climbers with similar goals.