SnowByrd Posted November 22, 2004 Posted November 22, 2004 Are these practical? What would you use them for? http://www.peglers.co.uk/scarpaphantomice.html Quote
Figger_Eight Posted November 22, 2004 Posted November 22, 2004 Ummm...practical for putting on at the base of a comp. route or packing into the m10 project you're working on. Quote
cracked Posted November 22, 2004 Posted November 22, 2004 They look killer for walking around the house. Might work well for mellow glacier slogs as well. Quote
cracked Posted November 22, 2004 Posted November 22, 2004 Snowbyrd, what's up with all the ridiculous questions?? You just linked to a page that says The Phantom Ice by Scarpa is an example of a boot/crampon hybrid. It was developed from the Ice Climbing World Cup, for use on ice, mixed and drytooling routes. FOR THE LOVE OF GOD, QUIT BEING STUPID!!! Quote
Dr_Crash Posted November 22, 2004 Posted November 22, 2004 Yummy Likely not good for your typical glacier / alpine travel unless you carry them in your pack as you would rock shoes. But to go trash on waterfall ice and practice drytooling, and save the nicer alpine boots for alpine, why not? And don't forget that these could help you solve issues in meetings when you need to look serious threatening to kick ass. drC Quote
SnowByrd Posted November 22, 2004 Author Posted November 22, 2004 Snowbyrd, what's up with all the ridiculous questions?? You just linked to a page that says The Phantom Ice by Scarpa is an example of a boot/crampon hybrid. It was developed from the Ice Climbing World Cup, for use on ice, mixed and drytooling routes. FOR THE LOVE OF GOD, QUIT BEING STUPID!!! Don't be an anus, Cracked. I am soliciting opinions for a friend who thinks he wants a pair. Do you buy gear just because the advertisement says you should? Well...maybe you do....but my question was, "ARE THEY PRACTICAL?" Or...is it just another pair of boots for the Emelda Marcos of climbing gear to spend his money on. Quote
PaulB Posted November 22, 2004 Posted November 22, 2004 I tried these on at the ROI sale in Vancouver on Friday. For $50, I almost bought them for a joke. They were definitely comfortable, but not all that practical unless you're a comp climber or seriously into mixed. However, if your friend needs new crampons and new boots just for ice climbing, then these might be a good option, assuming that whoever is selling them doesn't crank the price up to near their retail value (guessing C$600-700). Quote
cj001f Posted November 22, 2004 Posted November 22, 2004 If you have to ask, they aren't for you. Quote
John Frieh Posted November 22, 2004 Posted November 22, 2004 Snowbyrd, what's up with all the ridiculous questions?? You just linked to a page that says The Phantom Ice by Scarpa is an example of a boot/crampon hybrid. It was developed from the Ice Climbing World Cup, for use on ice, mixed and drytooling routes. FOR THE LOVE OF GOD, QUIT BEING STUPID!!! Don't be an anus, Cracked. I am soliciting opinions for a friend who thinks he wants a pair. Do you buy gear just because the advertisement says you should? Well...maybe you do....but my question was, "ARE THEY PRACTICAL?" Or...is it just another pair of boots for the Emelda Marcos of climbing gear to spend his money on. What specific questions did your friend have? Did they use the words: "are they practical" or was that you? Is he/she climbing double digit M lines? Quote
John Frieh Posted November 22, 2004 Posted November 22, 2004 But to go trash on waterfall ice and practice drytooling, and save the nicer alpine boots for alpine, why not? Mixed: yes. WI: no. Quote
SnowByrd Posted November 23, 2004 Author Posted November 23, 2004 I use mine for tap-dancing! This was my thought as well...maybe some perverse form of ballet or possibly an evil hockey skate? My friend, BY THE WAY, has never ice climbed in his life...so that is why I asked the question. Quote
Dru Posted November 23, 2004 Posted November 23, 2004 No that's jalapeno cutting plus itchy balls. Quote
Dr_Crash Posted November 23, 2004 Posted November 23, 2004 But to go trash on waterfall ice and practice drytooling, and save the nicer alpine boots for alpine, why not? Mixed: yes. WI: no. Interesting. Why would say no for WI? Given that the boots were specifically designed for ice comps, it sounds like it should be an application. drC Quote
John Frieh Posted November 23, 2004 Posted November 23, 2004 Think of those boots as high performance sport climbing slippers... should you get a pair you would fit them to maximize the sensitivity and performance they offer... snug. After a few weekends on free range water ice your boots would be too big as they would have to clip all your frost bitten toes off. Ice comps generally involve heated isolation rooms stocked with all the red bull and coffee you can drink... a place you can afford to change boots are your leisure and not risk frost bite. Finally (and this is just my 2 cents) IMO unless it is slow forming WI (homogeneous) you're going to want dual points anyways... Just out of curiosity... how much WI have you climbed? And what kind of boots do you wear? My leathers pull double duty: ice/mixed and alpine and I'm not trashing them in 1 season which I think is the original reason you gave... save your boots for the alpine. Quote
Dr_Crash Posted November 23, 2004 Posted November 23, 2004 If you'd size them as rock shoes, the toes argument definitely makes sense. Those boots actually come with dual points (and one can get rid of the heelp spur too; given how stiff I am I won't be heel-hooking anything anytime soon ), so they would work for regular WI I'd wager. I just got a pair of Freney XT for alpine and ice, actually, so I am just curious about these. They're outrageous and overkill, but really cheap (most likely because they're outrageous and overkill); a cheap pair of boots to kill is better than an expensive pair of boots to kill, even over a few seasons. Now a cheap pair of boots that won't work is still too expensive which is why I am asking for opinions. (Really, SnowByrd took on her to ask, but I'm interested .) drC Quote
Alex Posted November 23, 2004 Posted November 23, 2004 My advice: don't even think of getting them. You're friend should learn how to ice climb first before buying this (or any) type of specialized gear. That means - no ERGOnomic tools, no "fruit boots" (which is what real ice climbers call these). Quote
John Frieh Posted November 23, 2004 Posted November 23, 2004 Word. As Bouchard said: If you can't climb; gear won't help you. If you can climb you won't need all the crap (or something like that). Quote
SnowByrd Posted November 23, 2004 Author Posted November 23, 2004 Just out of curiosity... how much WI have you climbed? And what kind of boots do you wear? My leathers pull double duty: ice/mixed and alpine and I'm not trashing them in 1 season which I think is the original reason you gave... save your boots for the alpine. Oh....can I answer this? Please? Pretty please? None! (yet) This is my friend I was asking the question for....also known as Emelda Marcos Quote
RuMR Posted November 23, 2004 Posted November 23, 2004 Are these practical? What would you use them for? http://www.peglers.co.uk/scarpaphantomice.html Excellent lawn aerating device!!! I say go for it! Quote
SnowByrd Posted November 23, 2004 Author Posted November 23, 2004 Are these practical? What would you use them for? http://www.peglers.co.uk/scarpaphantomice.html Excellent lawn aerating device!!! I say go for it! Rumr! You're a fekin Genius! dr_C....I'll buy that second pair from you if you'll come over and walk on my lawn Quote
Dr_Crash Posted November 23, 2004 Posted November 23, 2004 I'll buy that second pair from you if you'll come over and walk on my lawn You say walk on your lawn but then you illustrate that with an icon of your . I think the latter is where those crampons would be headed to! drC Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.