There are other US locations in competition for hosting this facility- in fact every other location has a substantial mine already constructed.
The neutrino research is interesting, if you're interested in neutrinos. Me, not so much. I'm interested in the Icicle valley- that's where I get my rocks off. If a bunch of geeks in lab coats wants to prevent me from getting my rocks off, fuck 'em.
The worst part of this argument is when my lab-coated geeky friends look shocked when I let 'em know I'm opposed to DUSEL. They all make faces as if I've said something sacrilegious ("Hey guys, Christ was aiding on those nails. If he was really the son of God he could've freed that cross.")
They protest- "But we need neutrino research! You're standing in the way of progress. Who knows where this could lead?"
Screw research, screw progress. If it doesn't let me spend more time in the mountains, and if it doesn't keep the mountains pristine, then I don't want it.
I don't have to accept your definition of 'progress': cell phones, video games, monster trucks, frozen burritos, instant messaging, wireless networking- none of this shit makes my life richer, and I'd happily sacrifice it all for a single Icicle Valley.
Let Canada take all of our best and our brightest, just leave the Icicle Valley alone.
Squid has spoken.