I think it's silly to be so anti, "sport," climbing like Pope is. I remember a time when places like Castle Rock were a zoo on the weekends and today there are way more climbers then there were in the late 70s. Sure if all the, "sport," climbs got chopped some climbers would quit, but like Dick said there would be giant line ups on a lot of, "trad," routes. Furthermore Pope's whole reasoning breaks down when you start looking at old bolt ladders like Town Crier or the EB of SEWS. If we're chopping bolts shouldn't we chop those routes an teach that, "murderer of the possible," Fred a lesson?
On the other hand there has been a lot of abuse by some route setters. I recently did a route on Duty Dome that had at least 5 bolts placed right next to cracks that anyone with a reasonable rack and experience could easily protect.
For me it boils down to this.
I don't give a shit whether a bolt is placed on lead or rappel.
I like
Solid bolts that are placed to provide a decent amout of protection for a route and where the clips are at natural spots for someone climbing the route.
I dislike
Bolts next to cracks
Excessive bolting
Bolts placed at unnatural spots on a climb
Shitty drilling and placement
Bolted routes that are obvious squeeze jobs.
I think we as climbers should try and practice minimal impact but not zero impact. Possibly if this WCC gets going they could come out with guidlines for new routes and possibly some kind of approval process for new routes.