Thanks for the input. For future reference I am with RuMR and Snoboy.
I have done many "onsites" where I climbed up, placed gear, downclimbed to the ground, rested, and then fired the route. In my opinion we use gear simply to save our ass in case of a fall. The onsite or redpoint occur when you would be able to solo the route but you have placed gear for the chance that you might fail.
So I guess my opinion to my original question is Yes,Yes, pink. Thanks for your input.