sorry to keep posting but you're making me think.
You do bring up a good point about risk in climbing. I think there is a point where you degrade what climbing is to the point where it is something altogether different. Of course there is a spectrum and any given activity within climbing falls somewhere on the spectrum.
I personally don't care as much about how you define "climbing". I'm more interested in how that translates into route devolopment. Of course, certain ethics lead to unfortunate practices at the crag.