Actually, the head of our own military commissions has admitted that we've tortured just recently.   
  
I think the 'is it torture?' question has long been laid to rest, officially and unofficially.  No halfway serious person has asserted that the U.S. doesn't torture people in quite a while.   
  
Now, the argument is "Sure we torture, but these people deserve it." 
  
In a truly free and humane society, does anyone 'deserve' to be treated like a lab rat? 
  
Remember Room 101?  Where the worst thing in the world is?  It's now one of our 'tools' for 'fighting terrorism'. 
  
We're monsters. 
  
And, because we didn't defend the values we hold most dear and profess most often in troubled times, we're also physical and moral cowards, as well as liars.