Let's see people like to get fucked up and drunk sometimes. And that usually mean fights, pissing in the street, lots of noise, and shit that I don't want in my neighborhood. No matter what happens to Timmay's people are going to find a place to do this shit. This place closes or moves, the shit is still going to happen some place, to me it is better that it stays where it is at, like you said you can't expect quiet living in the U District, but it sounds like that is what you want. Also I think it is better to have areas that this shit happen so that it somewhat contained and spread out all over the city.
So stop fucking whinning and just move, already!
The only thing you will accomplish by closing them or having them move is having all that crap happen in some other area.
Part of what contains this is that there are more males in their 20's in the U district because it is close to the U, no? I am sure there are many pockets of nastiness everywhere, but maybe this one could be dispersed a little. If you don't get too many schmucks together, violence is less likely to break out. But wtf do I know, I'm no cop.