bellemontagne Posted October 18, 2002 Posted October 18, 2002 Okay guys and gals, I would love some feedback on a few different down sleeping bag models/brands (specifically in the 0 degree F range). I'm pretty knowledgeable about down, but I would be interested in feedback from users in a few different areas: 1) The performance of different shell materials like Gore Dryloft, Mountain Hardware's Conduit SL, and MEC's F.O.H20 laminate shell. 2) How well the zippers work - do they have a tendency to stick? Do they run pretty smoothe? 3) Has anyone had a problem with the construction of their bag? Any returns? 4) Are there any other consistent problems folks have noticed with these bags? Right now, I've narrowed my search down to a few bands/models. 1) Mountain Hardware Universe or Big Bang SL wth Conduit Shell 2) Marmot Never Summer with Dryloft shell option 3) MEC Swan with F.OH2O Shell I would love to buy a Western Mountaineering or Feathered Friends 800+ fill down bag with Dryloft, but my budget simply does not allow for such extravagance . Has anyone had any positive experience with any of these bags? It's important that I have a down bag that does have an effective water resistant shell becuase there will be times when it will be exposed to moisture. Thanks again for the feedback!!! [ 10-17-2002, 11:34 PM: Message edited by: bellemontagne ] Quote
Fence_Sitter Posted October 18, 2002 Posted October 18, 2002 the MEC bags are the shit, though the taffeta they use seems to be kinda weak... but if you ar3en't a thrasher, its all good adn the $$$ is right on... Quote
Lambone Posted October 18, 2002 Posted October 18, 2002 I was up at MEC in mid september and they had the Swan, or at least it was a 0 degree "dryloft" type bag on sale...check it out. I've got a WM Puma that I have hardly used, make an offer and maybe I'd be tempeted to sell it and get some new Ice boots... Quote
rbw1966 Posted October 18, 2002 Posted October 18, 2002 Belle-- I got a discount on my western mountaineering bag when my partner and I bought ours together. They dropped the price by 20% on the two bags. Check it out. Quote
joshs Posted October 18, 2002 Posted October 18, 2002 I have the Never Summer with Marmot's proprietary MemBrain shell material instead of Dryloft. I haven't used it much, but it seems warm enough and pretty waterproof. You can find them pretty cheap at a lot of places (though usually without the MemBrain/Dryloft shell). The zippers are pretty good (a LOT better than my old REI bag ) and I don't have any complaints about the construction. -Josh Quote
bellemontagne Posted October 20, 2002 Author Posted October 20, 2002 Well, I did some "field research" yesterday. The Marmot Never Summer bag rocks. It's easy to get into and zip up. My big complaint about sleeping bags are zippers getting caught. No problems here! This is definitely the bag I will be buying... I also tried out the MH Universe SL. This bag ain't the greatest. The zipper got caught several times. The biggest complaint is that it is hard to zip up and get the hood on when your inside the bag. I'm 5'10" and it was almost impossible to get myself inside the Size Regular bag. I had to get into the size large bag, and it wasn't too much easier to get the hood on and zip up. Plus, the Quantum expander feature seems to be a waste... Quote
bellemontagne Posted October 20, 2002 Author Posted October 20, 2002 Oh, and I checked on the MEC Swan bags... Unfortunately they are sold out! Quote
salbrecher Posted October 20, 2002 Posted October 20, 2002 Taiga bags are where it's at. I got a 800 fill dryloft -30 celcius for 550CAD , compared to $1000 for same deal but western mountaineering. Not as well constructed as WM but better than MECs. Zipppers don't stick, and very conservative in their temp rating of the bag. They're made in Vancouver (I think) and their store is right near MEC. Most of their Gore-Tex and other cloths (except fleece) I don't really like but their Down jackets and Bags are boss. Quote
cj001f Posted October 20, 2002 Posted October 20, 2002 quote: Originally posted by bellemontagne: 1) The performance of different shell materials like Gore Dryloft, Mountain Hardware's Conduit SL, and MEC's F.O.H20 laminate shell. My experience with MH's Conduit SL has been nothing short of horrible. It's neither waterproof, nor breathable - which would be alright if they dropped the price on their stuff. Avoid it like the clap. Carl Quote
Dr.Hook Posted October 20, 2002 Posted October 20, 2002 Sal, I'm currently looking at picking up one of those Taiga bags. I own one of their down/dryloft jackets and love it, especially the price. How long have you had/used the bag and how well does it pack down? In addition what faults have you found if any. Quote
salbrecher Posted October 20, 2002 Posted October 20, 2002 quote: Originally posted by Dr.Hook: Sal, I'm currently looking at picking up one of those Taiga bags. I own one of their down/dryloft jackets and love it, especially the price. How long have you had/used the bag and how well does it pack down? In addition what faults have you found if any. Ive had the bag for one heavily used year. The only problem I can find is that the bag makers assume that if you are tall (6'6") then you must be fat. Because it is an extra long and I am very "wiry" there is extra space in the bag making it a little colder, for me. I have used the bag to -23C and just wore my down jacket to fill up the space. It's not a lot of space or even a big problem it just doesn't fit like a custom bag. I think being "wiry" is the problem not the bag . Quote
Beck Posted October 21, 2002 Posted October 21, 2002 If you're going to buy a new bag, I strongly reccommend you get one with a drawstring footbag. You will love yourself for it for the next two-three decades you own the damn thing. Really. get one. Quote
salbrecher Posted October 21, 2002 Posted October 21, 2002 Since feet get cold easier wouldn't you want the air heat from the rest of your body to circulate down to your feet instead of isolating them? Just my figuring. Quote
Fence_Sitter Posted October 21, 2002 Posted October 21, 2002 mabe its cause of the oderiferous nature of feet perhaps? Quote
Beck Posted October 21, 2002 Posted October 21, 2002 hmm.. open footbag, lets you get up, put on boots, go fire up stove to get h20 boiling, while still in your sleeping bag...hmm... Quote
Fence_Sitter Posted October 21, 2002 Posted October 21, 2002 oh i get it...you said drawstring...so is it more like a zippered foot box then? Quote
salbrecher Posted October 21, 2002 Posted October 21, 2002 quote: Originally posted by Beck: hmm.. open footbag, lets you get up, put on boots, go fire up stove to get h20 boiling, while still in your sleeping bag...hmm... How do you light the stove with your arms in the bag? or do you have "drawstring" arm portholes to Quote
bellemontagne Posted October 21, 2002 Author Posted October 21, 2002 Does anyone have contact info for Taiga (URL, Phone Number)? I'm having a hard time finding info on them. Thanks!! Quote
troubleski Posted October 21, 2002 Posted October 21, 2002 quote: Originally posted by bellemontagne: Does anyone have contact info for Taiga (URL, Phone Number)? I'm having a hard time finding info on them. Thanks!! try this.... Taiga Works 390 W.8th, at Yukon in Vancouver, B.C. Mail Order: 604-875-6647 Store: 604-875-8388 Quote
salbrecher Posted October 22, 2002 Posted October 22, 2002 Taiga has nice fleece to. The rest sucks. Quote
jordop Posted October 22, 2002 Posted October 22, 2002 Be very wary of Taiga as a lot of their clothing absolutely bites and their return policy is absolutely non-existant if you have a problem. I was once there on a Boxing Day (seriously) and watched the staff deny a guy who got a jacket for XMAS witha stain on it. Down in all its forms has drawbacks; without dryloft your breath wets it out, with your body vapour wets it out. Neither dry well at all -- fine if you're only out for a day. Over a multi-day ski trip, wearing your belay clothes inside a sythetic bag makes the most sense -- absolutely no worry factor. Synthetic can dry out in a few hours in the sun too. My new Polarguard Delta (TNF Cat's Meow) is much more durable, warmer, and lighter than an old 3D bag which I ruined in a year. Synthetic is so cheap that you can sleep in the dirt and not feel bad. Embrace all gear that gets you closer to your inner dirtbag Quote
snoboy Posted October 22, 2002 Posted October 22, 2002 quote: Originally posted by jordop: Be very wary of Taiga as a lot of their clothing absolutely bites and their return policy is absolutely non-existant if you have a problem <snip> I have had real problems a long time ago with Taiga warranty. I think that they have the best deals on down & good basic fleece though. I have a pile jacket from 1989 that I thrash on and it's still in one piece. Just about needs its third zipper... A fiend of a friend (seriously) worked there and they were told that in warranty cases and returns "the customer is wrong" Quote
Dru Posted October 22, 2002 Posted October 22, 2002 In the book section of the Taiga store, shelved under "Wilderness Medicine", they have books about how to cure AIDS through prayer. Quote
Cpt.Caveman Posted October 22, 2002 Posted October 22, 2002 Wilderness medicines- Horsecock Cheese KGB Quote
Beck Posted October 22, 2002 Posted October 22, 2002 probably some seventh day adventist collective, then- those folk are WACKY! Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.