I've got em. The soles wear fast. They are soft, good hikers, good (easy) rock climber. They don't grip on snow much. They are too soft for good step-kicking in really hard snow. They are cold. I did some ice climbing in them this season (with G-12s, newmatic) and they are really way too soft for ice. Even on hard snow I was desperately wishing for stiffer boots. And the worst part: they are very flimsy, the many flaps of leather around the ankle are very weak, and I even ripped one of the instep eyelets out, making for even more insecure front-pointing. I'm not sure what they are good for, maybe easy snow, easy rock, many miles? They are NOT ice boots, no matter what Sportiva says. For hiking I'd get light hikers, and use them for alpine rock, too. For ice you want rigid. These might be a decent moderate snow, moderate rock, moderate hike type boot, but I'm not too happy with them. The falling apart really pisses me off.