no, matt, what he is saying is that if you put up a route, do it for yourself, in the manner you see fit and don't worry about others...
I personally agree with him, in part, because i'm sick of the TeamREI phenomenon that is replicating a gym experience outside instead of the other way around...
New people have never acquired one necessary "skill" that i believe is imperative for outside climbing...ie, being able to judge, for themselves, just how much risk they should take vs. how skilled they are at two things a.) protection and b.) climbing skills...
Go to a place like newhalem and you will see what i'm talking about...its GROSS!! Jeezus some sport areas make the gym look runout!!
Whatever happened to our sport??? Christ, when i started it would be inconceivable to actually sue someone over rockclimbing...now, its a real concern...and its because of this gym/REI phenomenon of getting everyone and their brother into it...
AND YOU KNOW WHERE I STAND WITH REGARDS TO IDIOTZ LIKE POPE/DWAYNER, but they do have their point...