to add to that, the only people I know who have to take their shoes "off" (pull the heel off as soon as they are done with the route) are climbing .13d in the gym, .14 when they find one in this area. The only two times I've had numb toes (and the screaming barfies equivalent in my feet, not hands) was a COLD COLD LONG crack climb, and my synchros a size small for socks and said all day adventure, AND, the time I wore my leathers when I should have worn my plastics... both were cases of not appropriate footwear for the situation.
depending on your foot shape, you may need to try some other shoes... Perhaps the mythos. they stretch real nice and mold to your foot...
hope you find something more comfey...