Let me tell you Dwayner, arguing with you is far more fun than having a one-sided pseudo-argument with some nameless bunch of continentals with illusions of grandeur.
I lean towards Sloth's side, btw.
Oh, and I don't think Lowell and whoever are really having the same argument. Twight isn't really as dumb as Lowell's post makes him look. I've always understood the anarchy cliche to refer to actual upwards progress, using the equipment at hand. Certainly Twight never extolled anarchy in equipment choice - if I remember his book correctly, the bolt section says simply "Not in my book." By the same token, his training regimen seems to have been rather structured, with six month cycles and whatnot. But, if you show up at the base with only what's kosher (sorry Dwayner), then you can climb by any means possible, and climbing is anarchy.