I've had very spotty service at Dave Page, although I understand that in the last couple of years his quality and consistency with climbing shoes has improved. I know that he does good work with hiking boots and mountaineering boots, unfortunately, he turned at least one pair of my climbing shoes and one pair of a friend's into hiking boots. Locally, Ramuta's is my best bet. They've been very consistent on my orders, and even rejuvenated a pair of Moccasyms, something I didn't believe could occur.
If you have the time, send the shoes south to the Rubber Room, formerly the cobblers of Wilson's Eastside Sports in Bishop, CA. http://www.rubberroomresoles.com/