Put this in your pipe and smoke it!

[Ratboy]

From what I read, the decision was more about states' rights than marijuana legalization, so it's not surpriusing that Thomas and Rehnquist were dissenting. Strange that Scalia wasn't.

[Stonehead]

In medical marijuana case, Supreme Court says everything is interstate commerce

[Billygoat]

I wish we could have a question and answer with the judges.

 

I would ask: "Why is marijuana illegal?"

 

I cannot think of any answer they could give that would keep me from asking this: "Why, then, are alcohol, tobacco, firearms, and supersized "happy" meals legal?"

[Dechristo]

"Why, then, are alcohol, tobacco and firearms legal?"

 

Gotta give the ATF a reason ta live.

[Stonehead]

I wish we could have a question and answer with the judges.

 

I would ask: "Why is marijuana illegal?"

 

I cannot think of any answer they could give that would keep me from asking this: "Why, then, are alcohol, tobacco, firearms, and supersized "happy" meals legal?"

 

Maybe the question should be reframed as: Why isn't marijuana legal?

 

How would alcohol and tobacco sales be affected if marijuana were legal and regulated for sale?

[chucK]

I think it would be more relevant to direct your question to the executive and legislative branches.

 

The supreme court decision has not commanded that MJ be illegal. It only says that in this case the executive branch has the power to enforce a federal law that contradicts state laws.

 

It is the federal law that is the problem not the supreme court decision.

[Billygoat]

That crossed my mind DeCristo

 

If it were legalized, RJR Reynolds would come out with a new kind of Marlboro Reds.

[slothrop]

I want to see marijuana commercials on TV.

[Billygoat]

Agreed Chuck.

 

I challenge anyone to answer my questions in a way that shows that any one of those "indulgences" has any reason to be illegal/legal different than the others.

 

Out of all five, marijuana appears to have the least harmful affects on society. And it is the illegal one