As a follow up to my question about a lightweight hardshell you guys have convinced me to get a soft shell. Now that I have been looking at them they look like a GREAT piece of gear because I have many occasions this winter felt like a swamp inside my hardshell.
I typically run hot so I want a softshell that is relatively thin. I climb, snowshoe, backpack, year round. So I think I would only use the softshell in the late fall, winter and early spring.
My thoughts are
1) Patagonia Houdini Patagonia lists this as a softshell, is it really? I haven't seen this in person so I am not sure it's what I want.
2) REI Mistral - I tried this on and liked the weight and the fit was OK.
3) Patagonia Dimension - I haven't tried this one but I really like the idea of the welded seams, it seems they would hold out water better.
4) Arc'Teryx Gamma MX - I liked the fit of this but dude, $299??? I don't think it's $150 better then the REI Mistral
5) North Face Apex Bionic - this one fit nice, seemed about the right weight.
It seems all the materials are equivalent, DRW, spandex, nylon, etc. True? Or are there specific materials that are really great on a softshell.
I am also thinking, no hood but am undecided...
Does anyone have experience with softshells that would help me pick one based on my uses? Does anyone have experience with the above jackets?