scott_harpell

Good luck guys... I'll be prayin for ya.

ding ding ding ding ding!

Martlet is damn funny. Got all you pinko commies swarming like a hive of pissed off hornets.

so far from your side all we have is ad hominum arguments and quotes from Moore. Methinks this 'evidence' is dubious at best.

is there a sacred golden rule which says that tragicomedy is not appropriate in documentary film making? isn't tragicomedy part of life as we know it? if it wasn't why would it have evolved to such a popular mode of communication in art as well as everyday exchanges? as for whether no documentary film makers has used tragicomedy before moore, i seriously doubt it. just give me time, i'll think of one. You quoted a precenedce and I showed you that there was none.

bt does bunel use comedy to illustrate his points? I must be old school because i feel that death deserves reverence... also i just posted the whole speech that Heston spoke... read it and you WILL see where the edits were made. JUST READ IT!

JB... I posted the ACTUAL speech from Heston... compare that with the creative editing in the movie and you will see the unethical doc practices that we are talking about.

j_b... read the articles... also... you state that otehr film makers have created such stories, but they do not call them documentaries and they do not make comedies out of tradgedies.

Will = 75

similar to a stockholders meeting... did they get cancelled because of september 11th?

Did you read?!? It was according to the law that they meet! Sheesh!

I am not suprised you are resorting to ad hominim arguments, but what else can you do when you have no facts to back up your side other than the voice of moor?

There is another quote from the article... read the whole thing not just the points that you agree with.

Heston's Actual Speech

source

are you saying that he fabricated large portions of his doc and that's ok? or that he didn't fabricate his doc? Make your position clear.

Which is it Scott? Is Moore a lying bastard, or "too honest?" Maybe you should pick more consistent sources. Hell, maybe you should think for yourself. Maybe you should give up and get some sleep. That was a very 'Moorish' edit... thanks for the example.

"smell the liberal guilt and the cloying of political correctness"

The right side... so you KNOW that you are right? huh... pretty arrogant... even for an american.

Hey Josh... I started the thread with 2 that you didn't read, so what is the use? You have obviously chosen to agree with him based on similar political affiliations anyway.

Yeah... really out for the people... raking in the deutch marks while trash talking his own people.

JoshK... what percentage of the articles you have contributed to this message board have been peer reviewed?

Staged Scene at the bank

Heston

History of KKK and NRA