panther, you are one scary fucker. "seditionists"? guess who were the seditionists in 1776?
the only real way to get rid of this problem is to make the idea of attacking the US irrelevant. if everyone who's now a terrorist were fat, busy, and happy, not a one of them would give a shit about learning how to make car bombs. not much of a means, but certainly the end.
the parallels to vietnam are numerous: enemy blends with the local population, hides in an extensive network of caves, and is opposed by a faction of dubious legitimacy who we're supporting with military advisors and airpower. yeah, yeah, it's not vietnam, but it's still going to drag out for years and end up a big fucking mess. just because we're aware of our mistakes doesn't mean we won't repeat them endlessly.
if we could kill osama bin laden tomorrow, great. i don't see how aiding the northern alliance will get us anywhere, but now that we've committed to it, we better wipe the hardcore taliban off the map and install their weaker members in a stupid coalition gov't with the alliance that will collapse in a few months. a way we might earn peace from afghanistan is to make sure the vultures in the region, especially pakistan, don't carve up the carcass for themselves. after we fuck up the place real good, we have to stand watch on the borders until it gets back on its feet again. if we don't help the afghanis get up after we beat them down, they'll just wait until we're not looking and strike back hard.