Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

So how risky is climbing really?

 

Climbers will be the last people to tell you that climbing isn’t a risky business. We spend a tremendous amount of time, money and thought in minimizing this risk, but ultimately we have accepted that there will always be a certain level of risk associated with our passion for climbing.

 

Unfortunately in the minds of average Mary and Joe’s, the risk that we accept is monumental, and this perception is fostered in part by the media that focuses in on almost each and every rescue operation or death in the mountains. So how risky is climbing really?

 

Statistics about climbing injuries and deaths as compared to other “risky” activities are hard to come by – in part it is difficult for researchers to get an accurate count of how many people are involved and the extent of that involvement. There are two primary ways of looking at the risks; 1) is to look at the likelihood that a participant will die or be injured in the activity and 2) what is the magnitude of deaths/ injuries as compared with other “risky” activities. One problem with many risk statistics is that it is easy and common to divide the total U.S. population by the number of incidences – easy but inaccurate. More difficult and less common are the studies that have used actual number of participants and incidents. I have used a few of each – but keep in mind the difference.

 

Accidental Deaths by activity for 2002

Activity Deaths

Climbing 34* A high year -18 in 2003

Motorcycle Rider 3215

Animal rider or occupant of animal-drawn vehicle 118

Drowning and submersion while in or falling into bath-tub 352

Fall involving bed, chair, other furniture, 785

Fall on and from stairs and steps 1598

Inhalation of gastric contents 369

Contact with hornets, wasps and bees 54

Lightning 66

Source: National Safety Council, Odds of Death Due to Injury, United States, 2002

American Alpine Club, Accidents in North American Mountaineering 2003

 

Voluntary Risks and likelihood of death (used number of actual participants in activity)

 

Voluntary Risk Risk of death/person/year

Smoking: 20 cigs/day 1 in 200

Drinking:1 bottle of wine per day 1 in 13,300

Auto Racing 1 in 5,900

Motorcycling 1 in 50

Rock Climbing 1 in 7,150

Taking contraceptive pills 1 in 5,000

Power boating 1 in 5,900

Skiing 1 in 430,000

Pregnancy 1 in 4,350 (UK)

Source: Dinman, B.D., The reality and acceptance of risk. Journal of American Medical Association 1980; 244(1): 1226:1228.

 

The above study is old and was done in the U.K. – would be great if someone knew of more current statistics. I know that life insurance companies have them down, but don’t know where to get them. Seems like if you ride your motorcycle to the crag while drinking a bottle of wine and sucking on your Marlboro after taking your birth control pills – you’re already DEAD.

 

And if the above Mary and Joe really want to get their knickers in a knot ---

 

An alcohol related motor vehicle crash kills someone every 31 minutes and non-fatally injures someone every 2 minutes (NHTSA 1993).

 

Each year, alcohol related crashes in the United States cost about $51 BILLION – (CDC web site) Who do you think pays that bill?

 

About 950,000 Americans die of cardiovascular disease each year, which amounts to one death every 33 seconds. In 2003, the cost of heart disease and stroke is projected to be $351 billion. (CDC web site) And one guess who pays this bill also.

 

Between 1988-1994 and 1999-2002, the prevalence of obesity among adults increased from 23% to 30%. The percentage of young people who are overweight has more than doubled in the last 20 years. The annual cost of obesity in the United States is about $117 billion in 2000. (CDC web site) Hey --- you mean I have to pay for this also??

 

Private Pilots are twice as likely to die flying as climbers are likely to die climbing. (Personal life insurance underwriter)

 

Occasionally there has been a suggestion that as a climber, I should be responsible for my own rescue costs if I ever need them. No problem, I’ll be glad to do it – right after every lost hiker, lost boater, smoker, drinker, and sedentary heart diseased person pays the FULL cost of their “risky” choices.

  • Replies 6
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted Images

Posted

Risk of exposure to sensionalist articles in the press by activity:

 

Climbing: 1 in 1

All others: 1 in many; except if it's newsworthy(like the drunk pilot of a hay cutting machine falling under the blades)

 

You've got to admit that climbing accidents are sexier to report on, what with all of us being irresponsible selfish daredevils.

 

drC

Posted
Risk of exposure to sensionalist articles in the press by activity:

 

Climbing: 1 in 1

All others: 1 in many; except if it's newsworthy(like the drunk pilot of a hay cutting machine falling under the blades)

 

You've got to admit that climbing accidents are sexier to report on, what with all of us being irresponsible selfish daredevils.

 

drC

 

yep! apparently climbing deaths are far sexier than death by contraceptive pill which seems to be a bigger liklihood! blush.gif

Posted
death by contraceptive pill which seems to be a bigger liklihood! blush.gif

 

blush.gif That must be why we men don't take the pill, since we already start with a lower life expectancy; we've got to minimize further risk...

 

drC

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




×
×
  • Create New...