jbarrett

Sent you a PM. Jonathan

Wow. I feel like I just trashed everyone's secret crush. All these folks going to bat for her. I have been reflecting on the experience and considering folks responses; maybe my tone was too harsh. I guess it comes down to what you go to the mountains for. Setting: fabulous. Line: I think the photo from summit says it all-very aesthetic. Approach: interesting. Maybe it was the actual rock climbing though that I felt was lacking. No sweet corners. No memorable hand-cracks. I was thinking about what a topo would look like for the route, if one were drawn. It would be hard to do, as there were no real defining features. Perhaps this is what I was suggesting. Sort of like the NE Buttress of Goode.

1)We traversed too low. It is less than obvious than it might seem, so I guess I would say if it doesn't look like 3rd class you are in the wrong spot. Just follow the beta. 2)Horseshoe Basin across to Sahale Arm. Descend the SW route from Buckner. 3 What do you mean???? I don't see much advantage to approaching via Boston Basin unless you were to carry over because unless you down-climb the face you are kind of stuck going across Horseshoe Basin and back to Sahale. 4)One axe + one tool is sufficient Current conditions: As of last weekend, we could see from Boston Glacier that there was still a line to be climbed, but it was melting out fast and there was a fair amount of brown strewn down the face. Take that as you may. How is that for mediocre advice?

Trip: Forbidden - NW Face Date: 7/27/2013 Trip Report: "An exceptional climb of purity." So says Beckey. "Its mixed character requires some genuine climbing and flexible alpine skills," he continues. A casual reader of the CAG will read this as if the route is a hidden gem, something that should have made it into a Nelson guide. But parse the language carefully and there is something more there that suggests at why the route may not be all that popular. Saturday morning, my partner and I left camp in Boston Basin at 5AM. The few other trip reports I was able to find suggested that the time to summit would be somewhere in the 10-12 hour range. We were able to reach the bypass right of Sharkfin Col in an hour. The finger of snow leading to it was still very good, and only minor loose scrambling led to the rap. A 30 meter rappel deposited us on the Boston Glacier where, to my chagrin, the plastic attachment point on my crampons tore. (Let that be a lesson to remember that time, in this case ten years, degrades these things as well as slings and cordage.) I was able to drill a second hole and make a workable situation. I doubt that Beckey had degraded plastic in mind when he wrote of "flexible alpine skills", but I employed some in the style of MacGyver none the less. The traverse to the North Ridge took about an hour. Torn Plastic Binding Looking Across Boston Basin To North Ridge The Higher Of Two Notches On North Ridge Only minor route finding across the glacier was necessary as the route was relatively clear and straightforward. The next question was where to cross. Being adventure seeking fellows that we were, we had left all route descriptions in the car, and chose instead to navigate by memory and intuition to allow in the spirit of adventure. Ultimately we chose the higher of the two ridge crossings. Beckey calls this the "less advisable" of the two choices and the reason was clear. The rap station was a large, detached block slung and wedged; it garnered a grade of C+ by my partner. Good enough, but not the kind of thing your mother wants to hear about. A 30 meter rappel put us at the bottom of a dirty slot and the flank of the Forbidden Glacier. From this vantage point it was clear that the base of the ridge was severely cracked up and passage on to the rib seemed to be in doubt. We knew that we needed to access it from the western edge and through the process of exploration were were able to swing around several large crevasses and down-climb some steep and fairly hard snow. In retrospect, if we had taken the lower North Ridge crossing, we would have been able to traverse the Forbidden Glacier lower and avoid some of these shenanigans. Looking Up the West Face Route: we accessed the rib off the glacier even with the small snow patch on the ridge Looking up at the face below the West Ridge, it was fairly evident to me why Beckey calls that means of approach "possible, but less advisable". This was essentially what we said to a few lads the day we hiked out who also planned on doing the NW Face. "Yeah, you could get down that way, but I certainly wouldn't suggest it." Access on to the ridge was by means of down-climbing into the moat (a boot ax belay here to further demonstrate those flexible alpine skills; it looked like a previous party had rapped off a bollard), over a four foot block of snow (which likely won't be there much longer) and onto the rib. Looking Down At The Access Snow Block Getting On The Rib Finally on the rib. It was 10AM when we started simul-climbing, and immediately I saw a significant short coming to the route. The rib faces NW, obviously, rising at about a 60 degree angle. Where is the sun at ten in the morning? To the SE at nearly the same aspect. For much of the route it was almost impossible to look up the line. In my mind, this was a significant detraction from the route. Starting Up The Route On 4th Class Terrain. A single long simul-climb took us through 3rd/4th class, loose and poorly protected ledges and to the minor horn about 1/4 of the way up. From there we found the "genuine climbing" Beckey talks about. It was mostly low 5th with short sections of 5.6 terrain. We passed the crux chimney to the left via ledges. About two-thirds the way up, we started to pitch things out. There was some clean slab with sparse protection that I found to be unadvisable to simul-climb. Three or four more pitches put us on top three hours and change after starting up. Looking Down The NW Face From The West Ridge. Was the rock good? It was better towards the top, akin to the West Ridge in that there were a lot of flakes that seemed like they might be detached but aren't. There was some loose junk but not a ton. Was the line aesthetic? It sweeps straight downward from summit to base. Beckey says, "there are many minor variations" which is true and this detracts from the sense that you are climbing a true line. What about that word "genuine"? If you take his statement to mean "real", then yes the climbing is more than just 4th class. And fairly sustained in the top two-thirds. A note about the descent. Due to large numbers of people coming up and going down the West Ridge, it took nearly three hours to return to the West Ridge notch. For regulars, this may not surprise you, but for those unfamiliar with the route, keep in mind that this short descent will take far longer than you think. As well, the snow gulley is melted out, and we used the rap stations to its left. Putting on my crampons after the rappels, the plastic tore again and I was forced to jury rig a repair because the strap was no longer long enough to reach. Argh. 'Biner Fix And of course, the hike out was the counterpoints of flowers blooming and ice crashing down the northern faces of J-Berg. Was the route "exceptional" as Beckey puts it? What does that even mean? I guess I am willing to admit that I haven't climbed enough in the Cascades to say whether the route was exceptional relative to other such lines available. Compare it to the North Ridge of Stuart, and I would not even say they are in the same league. What about the "purity". Sure, it is a direct line to the summit from the glacier. In another sense, the route was pure because we saw no evidence of other climbers on route. No rap slings, pins, fixed gear, or even any trash. So I guess in that sense it was pure. (I did note a fixed, knotted, and very weather-bleached rope hanging further east of the route by about 30 meters midway up the face. I would be interested to hear that story if someone knows it.) A special note to some friends who helped us out in Boston Basin. Due to a miscommunication we left our stove in town (brought a canister and pot though. Doh!). These fine people allowed us to brew up enough hot water to cook dinner for both nights. Thanks for saving our bacon on that one! (Is it an "alpine skill" to mooch off of others bivied nearby?) Frolicking Home Gear Notes: Busted crampons, no stove, and finicky water filter all necessary for success. Small rack of nuts and singles to 2 inches with doubles in the finger size. A dozen slings. Sunglasses 'cause you'll nuke your eyes looking uproute otherwise. Patience for getting down the West Ridge. Approach Notes: Use the access col to the right of Sharkfin Col The higher of the notches crossing the North Ridge was ok, but not great. Make sure you go all the way around to the west side before you decide you can't get on the ridge.

PM Sent

PM sent

Trip: Mt Buckner - North Face Date: 7/13/2013 Trip Report: Myself and three others climbed the North Face of Buckner on Saturday. We approached from Cascade Pass and spent Friday night at Sahale Arm. After a mildly stormy evening (where we learned that three can fit under a MSR Twin Sisters), the skies cleared as forecasted. We were moving by 4:15, just as the first glow was appearing over the horizon. We crossed over Sahale while the sun was just climbing over the horizon and descended onto the Quien Sabe Glacier. The route then became unclear for us. Where to cross Boston Peak? The beta suggested that a loose 3rd class ramp would take us on the Boston Glacier approximately 200' below the summit. Not having the actual height of Boston to go from, we were left with the two other descriptors. Just how "loose" was loose? What qualified as a "ramp"? Beckey calls it "easy rocks"; sandbagger! To be blunt, I think we fouled this up crossing too low and therefore having to traverse farther and across less safe terrain. It is not an understatement to say that Boston is a total chosspile. The march across to the base of Buckner went quickly, and we chose the North Face proper as the bergschund across the NF Couloir was totally open. Climbing on the face was in stellar condition: Styrofoam snow from bottom to top. We were able to do it in three long running belays each with four pickets between belay point. Around 11AM we popped out into the sunshine essentially at the summit. The descent was via the Southwest Route and across Horseshoe Basin. The suggestion was to cross at 6400 feet which was easier said than done. It appeared that one could take the small finger of snow over the ridge line, but we chose instead to drop all the way under ridge that divides the Sahale and Davenport Glaciers. The final climb back to camp is a bit of a grunt. Nelson calls it 600 feet, but I think it is at least twice that from the toe of the ridge. We were back at camp by six, taking our time on the return. Now for the photo onslaught. (I have conditions photos of J-Berg etc from camp as well as Boston Glacier if someone is interested). Sahale Arm: the Glacier and Avalanche Lilies were in bloom, but no berries yet. Dawn on the Sahale Glacier If you imagine the summit as a gaping maw, we passed over the sleeping beast's tongue. (The following photos loaded weird...) Dropping down from Sahale onto the Quien Sabe glacier [ Traverse to Boston Is this the right "ledge"? What about this one? This looks like the best of the worst. Starting up the North Face And up... And up some more... Yeah, the climbing was that good. We had followed tracks from an earlier party. I think I remember that the summit register had us as the fifth or sixth party this year. Beautiful snow even to the summit in the sun Traversing across Horseshoe Basin Looking back at Buckner's SW route. Somewhere we passed by the old mine, but I did not see it. The desk ranger at Marblemount said that at one time there were plans to blast a rail tunnel under Buckner connecting Skagit Queen Mine to the Horseshoe Basin Mine. Can anyone verify this? Our route in red Gear Notes: Two tools 6 pickets Handful of screws (never used) Approach Notes: Snow free to Sahale Arm Bivy spots are snow free and there is running/pooled water

PM sent