I moved to the PNW just last year. My perception of the Mountaineers is similar to everyone else's. I am a member and have taken their Navigation Class and intended to take the Basic Climbing Class. I have been climbing rock for over 4 years and have done some ice climbing, all back East. I have taken similar courses through the AMC (Appalachian Mountain Club), but unfortunately they don't honor that experience. On the other hand, the AMC courses didn't cover glacial travel (not too many glaciers in New England <grin> ). So I hope to learn a few things in the course, although it does concern me that there are so many accidents on the Mountaineers’ trips/climbing classes. I just looked through my copy of the 1998 Accidents in North American Mountaineering and found reports of two fatalities and several accidents.
I have had to deal with plenty of the bureaucracy of the Mountaineers, however, that is my own choice because I have chosen to be a member (for now at least). My question to the group is this: Is the frustration with the Mountaineers (or the WAC) unique to this organization? Or is it just a consequence of a group that size?
As an AMC member of several years I have not heard many complaints about the AMC. Maybe I just haven’t been aware of it. All of my experiences with that group have been wonderful. I have met a great group of climbers, hikers, backpackers, and others. Then again, this is my experience. Others may have different views.
Are there any suggestions or solutions we could suggest to the Mountaineers or the WAC? There seems to be a lot of opinions, ideas, and the such on this thread. Maybe we could get a list together of problems, suggestions, and solutions and send them to the Mountaineers. After all we all share the same public lands. We have a right to voice our opinions.
Any thoughts on this?