Jump to content

counterfeitfake

Members
  • Content count

    1640
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by counterfeitfake


  1. Here's the NPS release:

     

    http://www.nps.gov/grte/parknews/news-release-11-89.htm

     

    And the report from their blog when it happened back in August:

     

    http://gtnpnews.blogspot.com/2011/08/climber-rescued-from-north-ridge-of.html

     

     

    Sounds like a complicated situation to me. I'm not totally sure the descending climber did the wrong thing. They had communicated a helicopter already, and were given every impression a rescue was underway. He felt he could descend safely by himself. If he'd waited around, how long would it have taken them to make 2 helicopter rides? As it was, just getting the one climber off the mountain had the rescue effort bumping up against night time, if he'd waited he could very easily have ended up spending the night up there by himself. I'm not sure the slap on the wrist is appropriate.

     

    And obviously the facts aren't all clear, but it seems like calling for a rescue in the first place might have been a pretty irresponsible decision. Neither climber was injured, and they had a rope and set of gear. Calling for a helicopter rescue is putting other people in danger to fix your mistake.


  2. Hahaha, "full-blown aid", I like it.

     

    Saving Liberty Crack for a long day in June when the snow might reach to the top of the scrambling? One can hope! :-)

     

    Think more like July, probably! I did it 4 years ago around July 4th, and there's still lots and lots of snow at the pass, that time of year.

     

    We did a lot of french-freeing and outright aid. I'd like to go back some time and free a lot more of it. We did the entire thing in one day and it was good. Next time I might do the pre-fixing approach and then lower/drop all the aid gear after P3 just lighten up.


  3. Jon: Good to meet you! Glad you guys got it done, I hope at least some of what we told you was useful!

     

    Jared: Thanks, and thanks for the beta! At least some of what you told me was useful! It's impressive to me that you got this done a few years ago, I was glad to have a few years of extra climbing experience under my belt.

     

    D-Rep: Yeah, it was a bunch of mismatched schedules, wasn't it? You'll see me at the gym and cragging around until the weather gets real bad, let me know if you need a partner in the meantime.


  4. Trip: South Howser Tower, Bugaboos - The Beckey-Chouinard

     

    Date: 9/4/2011

     

    Trip Report:

    The Beckey-Chouinard!

     

    This route initially captured my imagination on my first trip to the Bugaboos in 2006, when I talked to a couple of climbers staying in the Kain Hut with us who had just gotten back from their climb. At the time, I didn't really understand what the route meant, but I knew it was well beyond my abilities and wondered if I would ever be the kind of climber who could accomplish something like that.

     

    The answer is yes, barely.

     

    I hadn't been climbing much this year, a combination of many excuses including bad weather and a hurt finger. On August 1 my buddy Doug asked me if I wanted to go climb the Beckey-Chouinard over Labor Day. Chances like this with a rock-solid partner don't come up all the time, so I said yes and knew I needed to get in shape. I climbed as much as I could during August and by the beginning of September, felt almost ready.

     

    Doug and I left Thursday after work, and drove into BC in two shifts. After sleeping in the car for a few hours we finished the drive through significant rain showers, and the unwelcome sight of snow on the hills around us. We hiked in through unsettled weather, and when we got to Appleby we found a couple inches of snow on everything. The cute but very serious custodian chick said we were brave. We were concerned.

     

    6121958589_ac7ebb130e_z.jpg

     

    6147810503_642cb6f41f_z.jpg

     

    6122524462_2e18fa0b72_z.jpg

     

    Our tentative plan had been to haul all the way into the East Creek Basin but the snow and the cold encouraged us to set up camp at Appleby instead. We started talking about other routes in the area. Neither of us were willing to say "plan B" but we were both thinking it.

     

    We goofed around for a while and then went to bed. It was a cold night, we put on everything we had and were still a little chilly. The alarm went off at 4, Doug didn't hear it, I took a quick vote and nobody wanted to get up so we slept until the sun hit our tent. Morning was bright and cold. We ate breakfast and headed up to scout out the approach to South Howser and climb Pigeon. The B-S col was in the best shape I'd ever seen, and both my previous trips were in July! We found up to 8 inches of fresh snow on the upper Vowell glacier.

     

    6122577198_64573883c6_z.jpg

     

    6122602246_900249a20f_z.jpg

     

    6122604932_9edaa2be47_z.jpg

     

    6122634086_d0b518e338_z.jpg

     

    When we got to the P-H col we could see that the West Ridge of Pigeon still had snow on it. We decided to give it some time to warm up, and scout our descent into the East Creek Basin. The fresh snow turned out to be a blessing. We were able to set up 2 raps off boulders over the steepest part (I have never heard of this idea before, but it was perfect for us), and then kick steps all the way down to the bivy sites.

     

    6122638124_8bdc338c2d_z.jpg

     

    6147861105_6f5348c2a3_z.jpg

     

    6122653916_130e38b404_z.jpg

     

    With good steps put in, we hoofed it back up to the col. We decided the best plan was to abandon the climb of Pigeon and get back to camp to turn in early. But first we scouted out the descent off South Howser. It looked good! We went home and cooked dinner, and then I tossed and turned and caught some sleep.

     

    The alarm went off at 2 am, we got up and ate, and stole away under starlight. It felt surreal to be a tiny pool of light alone on the glacier with the world quiet around us. We retraced our steps of the previous day and our timing seemed perfect, reaching the boulder hopping section below the route just as the sky was getting light.

     

    6122681528_5fdafd589c_z.jpg

     

    Hundreds of feet of scrambling later, Doug took the first lead. The plan was to simul the first 3 pitches, to below the first 5.10a pitch. He got off route but it didn't matter much. He led the next pitch too, then I took a couple leads.

     

    6122700850_2aab786d4d_z.jpg

     

    6148410598_aca79a07f4_z.jpg

     

    6147880339_7f8a9b5898_z.jpg

     

    And then we swung a few more leads before reaching the big bivy ledge.

     

    6147880363_b55d59ce24_z.jpg

     

    6122711954_186d85642b_z.jpg

     

    I'd been warned the 2 pitches off the ledge, on the Great White Headwall, were "real asskickers". This is 100% accurate. The pitches are sustained and are LONG, about 60 meters each. Doug took the first one, a really nice hand/fist crack to a pedestal, to more cracks to a little face climbing.

     

    I took the second, hands and fists in a corner, to nice face cracks, then back into the corner for a squeeze finish. I'd read you can do this pitch with a pack on, and it's true, although if you had an axe on that pack it would suck. The crux for me was hugging a snow-covered chockstone and pumping out with freezing hands, trying to muscle my way up 3 times and realizing each time I didn't have the strength, before getting smart and using my feet.

     

    6147880391_2116848553_z.jpg

     

    6147880401_043d58f6a2_z.jpg

     

    When the pitch was done, I breathed a sigh of relief, despite the hole in my ankle I had just noticed was filling my shoe with blood. We had finished the hardest portion of the route, just 3 pitches and some scrambling to go, and the sun didn't look too low in the sky yet. Doug took the next lead and somehow linked up most of the next 2 pitches. I took the final lead, tension-traversing around the corner and then up the gully to the rap station. By now it was getting pretty dark...

     

    6122714976_7685110d10_z.jpg

     

    The scramble after the rap was snow-covered and poorly lit, and we wasted some time swapping leads because I was unsure of where I was going. It's actually straightforward, the real ridge you can see is the one you are heading for.

     

    Doug found the rap anchor and brought me up as the last rays of sunlight were fading.

     

    6122175219_b3a9909133_z.jpg

     

    6122719554_865e216093_z.jpg

     

    6122723466_c147968f65_z.jpg

     

    The raps started pretty badly for us. The first one was straightforward, but on the second one the rope got stuck below us, and I rapped down to free it. After a whole lot of dicking around I got it out of the crack, and prusiked back up again.

     

    Now it was Doug's turn. He rapped down and couldn't find the bolts, so he prusiked up and tried a different direction, which also didn't have any bolts. I was getting really cold and worrying about the possibility of a bivy, which would have been a bad scene. But on his third try he located them. When I followed him down I saw why he'd tried two other choices first: the rap was very diagonal, over a low angle and narrow ridge, which on that day was covered in ice and snow. If you slipped and blew it, you'd pendulum off the ridgecrest and sideways into the dark unknown. Sketchiest rap I've ever done.

     

    Mad props to Doug for saving our asses. He can save yours too, if you read this.

     

    After this, the raps were straightforward. Doug went down first on every single one and did a fantastic job of finding the anchors quickly. As we lost elevation it warmed up and the wind subsided, and we started to feel like things would be okay. We'd spend the night in our tent, instead of cuddling under a pop-tart wrapper. The last rap took us over the bergschrund and onto soft, low-angle snow, upon which I knelt and deposited grateful kisses with my catastrophically chapped lips. From here it was an easy slog back to camp.

     

     

    I'm still kind of in shock that we got this done. It's been the most ambitious climb on my to-do list for so long, and it always seemed out of reach. Next year, I'll have to find some other whale to chase, but for now, it's time for fall!

     

    Gear Notes:

    Nuts, double Camalots from # .4 to 3 and a single #4. We had 3 tiny cams which weren't necessary and they were gummed up anyway.

     

    Approach Notes:

    Round trip from Appleby is reasonable. We were able to leave crampons and axes at the top of the B-S col, this is totally conditions dependent. Moving slightly faster, or having a couple more hours of daylight, would have made things easier.


  5. a couple of teens...if it were my son and daughter... only dumb people are breeding...

     

    You guys are RIGHT, but don't you realize how OLD you sound? Maybe if you tried talking to these climbers like they were your peers instead of your kids, you'd get better results.


  6. A harness is the last place I'd try to spend money for performance, you don't need to spend a lot of money on a "fancy" harness for the alpine. If you're broke, go ahead and bargain hunt. Anything with 4 gear loops will work just fine.


  7. If you mean, you should have shit figured out before you get there, I agree.

     

    But that is definitely the hardest part of the west ridge and it's not surprising that a party would run into some difficulty there.

     

    granite_climber, why did you choose to descend the WRC? What is that descent like?


  8. I have climbed Stuart three times and always wanted crampons once you descend over the east summit. There is a glacier there. A small one. Is is gone?

     

    Jesus kevbone.

     

    There's a "permanent snowfield" there and no, it's not GONE, but in the warm August afternoon it's soft and you can walk down it, or you can downclimb choss on skier's right side.


  9. Echoing what others said, if you do it in the afternoon you can probably get away without crampons (and an axe if you're daring) but in the morning I wouldn't even think about it.

     

    Dont you need the crampons for the descent?

     

    Down the Cascadian? No.


  10. You're actually advocating intentional pin scarring over a bolt? That is pretty radical. You're sounding more like a zealot- you may have strong feelings about this but you don't speak for everyone.

     

    Climbing protection has improved since that first bolt was planted.

    Are you sure about that? Do you know when that bolt was put in?

     

    I am POSITIVE that the climber who replaced that bolt understands there are potential nut placements. Most I have talked to believe those placements are dodgy. I won't contest that they might hold a fall but I wouldn't call them bomber either. By my memory it seemed like an outward tug might blow the placements.

     

    On issues like this, consensus is what is important, and the voices of those who are active in maintaining the area should carry more weight. Maybe you're one of them, I don't know. But I do know where you can reach a bunch of others, if you want to talk to them about this.


  11. The old bolt was removed, and a new one put in it's place?

     

    Did you actually fall on your nut placements, or did you just feel like they were bomber?

     

     

    I haven't been climbing at Index for 17 years, but everybody I've ever talked to about that bolt was in favor of replacing it, and nuts in that crack never seemed very confidence-inspiring to ME, when facing a potential ledge fall and broken ankle.


  12. I don't have any beta on what you're suggesting, but I did the east ledges descent a month ago. They are loose and sketchy, but reasonable if you're experienced. Especially if you've done the whole T-F traverse already, I'd think you would be in the right frame of mind to handle them.

     

    The most important thing is, get low, stay low. Do at least 5 half-rope rappels- enough that further rappelling would seem to take you over cliffs toward the glacier- and do not gain any altitude while traversing.


  13. Nice trip! Did you feel like you were on-route in the chimneys? When I came down them in July last year after doing the NF, they were almost all straightforward scrambling. But I have no idea how much snow is in them right now. I notice you followed the time-honored tradition of taking no pictures on the descent! Funny how that works.


  14. Has anyone been up the Fisher Chimneys lately? I am wondering how much snow is still left in them.

     

    I've been planning on taking a group of fairly novice climbers up them this coming weekend. I've climbed down them before and found it chill, and I'm pretty sure the rest of my group can handle the rock climbing, but if they're a mix of steep snow and rock it might be an issue for some of them.

×