Uh Oh, my first entry into the frothy ferment that is cc. I expect to get lambasted and harangued for whatever I say, so lemmehavit. . .
I agree with sh that a routes rating "feel" depends on its pro. For instance my onsite of celestial groove at p.g. last weekend left me a little surprised at how thin the LHC above the ramp was to protect. I loved the perfectly spaced edges every two or three feet or so for my left foot. I felt that the rating was entirely reasonable for a tr, but leading it left me feeling 10b, easily. I felt it was way harder than my Last Rights os, which is just to the right about 100' or so, and rated 10a. I'm sure though, that upon return I would feel that the rating would feel more reasonable.
For a case in point, the start of CG left my partner - and several others that day - totally stymied on tr. I felt it was a V2 breeze, so I realize that ratings are subjectively based on an individual's particular technical ideosyncracies.
I agree with so many about Index, that once you wire, the ratings are spot on. On a recent tr of Cunning Stunt I felt it was even a little soft, so I tried the red point and backed off the bolted traverse. That move above is forizzle, and made the thing feel sandbagged - gofigga.
For Classic Crack in lw I've seen it soloed in flip-flops. Once I learned to anchor bomber jams it feels straight-on 5.8. Again, I've never thought that ratings were for the onsight, but more accurately represent the style and abilities of the fa party.
Dogleg crack in lw has one awkward move to the right, but it is totally 5.8+. The climb just to the right, though - Hind Quarters - is rated .10-, but the damn thing has a super slopy move over a bulge that I had to yard throgh. Someone, please give me the beta on this. Right heel hook?
I want to lead BOC and RC in one pitch, so I've made sure to have Coach's Crack wired at the UWrock. If you can send and downclimb coach's from sit to sit using only the crack for feet BOC should feel just jiltingly exposed, but entirely doable, I hope - wishmeluck But then again, maybe I just have the perfect hand size for it.
If your hands haven't bled, you've never led a crack, so if it hurts alot, you must be doing something right. Eventually the pain will go away as your flesh adjusts to the abuse. A hex on tape