Jump to content

I admit, I am (mostly) Anti-Bolt


Terminal_Gravity

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 145
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

quote:

Originally posted by Terminal Gravity:

I have not purchased a Freind since I found out that Jardine was a hold chopping muther fucker. Pope have you?

Not trying to antagonize here TG, but Jardine sold the rights to the design a long long time ago, I think your sentiment is a little misplaced.

Jardine is a asshole for chipping that...but what about Lynn using the chipped holds on her "free" ascent of the Nose (I think Lynn is awesome, but shouldn't that be The Nose VI 5.13+ A0?)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

quote:

Originally posted by Terminal Gravity:

Will:

I was hoping to read a comment from you about my original posting.

I didn't comment because I basically agree with what you wrote. However, I do believe that the term "environmental damage" in this argument goes beyond the destruction of the physical rock and contains the element of destruction of the aesthetics. Bolts are ugly, so is chalk...chalk washes off.

Some will call me a hypocrite because I say if you can't climb it (established routes) without adding bolts then stay off it, yet I go out and climb wall routes that have chicken bolts added or rivet and bolt ladders on them. I've never added a fixed piece to an established route intentionally (I've had passive pieces that I couldn't clean and one cam that welded when I fell on it) but I have used the chicken bolts. I clipped the new bolt on Kor-Ingalls, I also clipped that first bolt on Serenity crack.

Does that make me a hypocrite? Maybe, but I do it my way, you do it yours...and if you come in my back yard and retro-bolt something just because you can't get up it in the same or better style than the FA, then expect it to get chopped.

Here's a little story of how I went from a passive dislike of bolting to an active one:

I worked a short,hard crag route in Alabama that was originally done with pre-placed trad pro. My goal was to do it placing the pro on lead. This route is only about 40 ft, but the climbing is hard and sustained (I don't generally use ratings in posts here, but maybe numbers will put this into perspective...the route is 5.12b R, the crux sequences both involve big dynos over brass nuts). I worked it on top rope for a few days, mixing it in with my other climbing. I worked out the sequences the first day, fired it clean on TR the second day. On the third day of work a week later I just worked it looking for the most feasible stances to place the gear and exactly what gear to place where. It was only going to accept three pieces of gear and two of these were being placed from very pumpy stances. Falling while placing the first or second pieces would mean groundfall. About a week later I went back and put in several ascents on TR stopping to place the gear over the course of a weekend. I felt ready and made a plan to come back the next weekend with my most trusted partner, to do one TR ascent, rest and wait until conditions were cool in the late afternoon. Forecast was for rain the next weekend so we stayed close to home (it never rained). Mid week we roll over there and I'm just amped, sweating and nervous before we even get out of the parking lot. I was psyched, nobody around but us, this could be my finest accomplishment or put me in the hospital and we'd soon find out. We walk up to the pinnacle that the route is on and I drop my pack and start gearing up. My partner suddenly goes "Holy shit, what the f$&*# is that?!" Some bastard had retrobolted the line as well as the three other lines adjacent to it. Needless to say I was pissed, and although I probably could have got on it and just done my thing ignoring the bolts, it destroyed that psyche I had going and I knew without the right frame of mind I could not do the route safely (or at all). After the inital anger wore off I examined the bolts...the stupid bastard didn't even place them in good places for clipping (I was scoping them from the ground). We did some bouldering, climbed a few easy classics, then went into town. We bought a wrench and hacksaw, grabbed the claw hammer and prybar in my partner's rig and chopped the line and one of the adjacent lines (as far as I knew at the time the other two were FA's by the bolt-whore, later I found out they were also retro-jobs). We show up next weekend and the little bolt-whore had re-bolted it. We didn't have the chopping gear so we did other stuff and went home. I left the southeast soon after for grad school and never did the route. If you are ever climbing at Sandrock, AL the route is Called Tales from the Hard Side and is located on the Holiday Block.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That was a nice site Alpine Tom, indeed it was, but it was NOT about moondancing. Moondancing is about DANCING, as the name implies. It is a style of dancing, non-pornographic, very stylized and orchestrated, relying on terrific foot-speed and coordination, along with certain sleight-of-foot tricks that can take years to master. It has actually helped tremendously in my climbing. In fact, I think it's the main reason I have climbed 5.13, although only on rap-bolted sport routes.

So please don't criticize what you don't understand.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks for the story Will. It's a good one and I can comiserate with you. It should be a good example to those that would bolt with out thinking.

I'm glad that you brought up chalk. I have recently been rethinking it's use. I've decided to only use chalk where it is already there. If I can't climb aesthetically clean rock without chalk< I'll climb something else.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

quote:

Originally posted by sexual chocolate:

That was a nice site Alpine Tom, indeed it was...

I appologize. I usually try to avoid the cheapest possible humor. I went out on google to see if I could figure out what moondancing was (why anyone would search for anything in the Internet with Yahoo is beyond me) and I found this, and I couldn't resist. I guess I'm in a pissy mood because I've been fighting with a Compaq server all day. (Time to look into backhoe driving school again.)

Anyhow, sorry for the smart-ass website posting.

(It was sort of funny, though, wasn't it?)

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




×
×
  • Create New...