Jump to content

McCain speech


chesterboo

Recommended Posts

Yo Fairweather: I was just kidding about the cultural superior part - at least in part.

 

I actually DO prefer the culture here to that in Michigan, but I knew if I put in a line about "cultural superiority" you'd be sure to get wrankled 'cause that has been your schtick for something like 6 years here on cc.com: "You Seattle liberals are all so smug and you drive Volvo's, too... blah blah blah."

 

Relax, dude. Or are you REALLY arguing that racisim and racial tension isn't worse in Detroit?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 141
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I've been holding my head in shame all these years for nothing. I was 11 in 1968 and apparently my political note-taking was a little off.
Considering this perception of yours (at this time), of national politics, at that time, leads me to speculate on your inward reckoning and judgments on the subject of Race - as well as pointing to your ostensible political mis-perceptions.

 

Meanwhile, every time I visit I still find the racial attitudes there to be very different from those here in Seattle. I never get the "what the f*@! you looking at, white boy?" kind of reaction around here and I have not encountered anybody here with even close to the racist attitudes of kids I grew up with. We in Seattle are as segregated as Detroit, to be sure, but I don't think we openly display the same measure of racism. Would you agree with this, or do you think your inter-racial social group is the norm in Michigan? Really? Because virtually EVERYBODY I've talked with about this who lives in southern and particularly southeastern Michigan or comes from there has agreed that the West Coast is way less tense in this regard. I just ran into somebody at the gym the other day who agreed -- and if he says so it must be true.
In my experience, with rare exception, a strong measure of ethnocentrism is the norm the world over. It doesn't matter if "openly displayed" or held inward, politely. No, I don't agree southeastern Michigan is escalated above most other areas of this country in racist values held by its inhabitants. I'm not discounting its presence, but asserting that the lack of open displays are not evidence of its diminishment or absence.

 

 

Maybe it is different in the UP, where there really aren't any black people, are there?

Again, this statement doesn't address the presence of racism, but simply the lack of its expression.

 

Polite racism, though more palatable to some, is no less vile than more crude expressions.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Whatever, DC. After all the discussion you've come around to what was my actual point in the first place: it is not really surprising to hear somebody from Michigan say they'd never vote for a black presidential candidate. And you appear to agree with my secondary point: racism tends to be expressed more openly in Michigan than in Seattle. (Scroll up and you'll see that I specifically noted in one of my first posts in this sub-topic that we are just as segregated as Detroit and I didn't and don't dispute your assertion that there is "hidden" racism here.)

 

Michigan. Land of racial bliss. NOT. North. More "enlightened" than south. NOT NECESSARILY.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Whatever, DC. After all the discussion you've come around to what was my actual point in the first place: it is not really surprising to hear somebody from Michigan say they'd never vote for a black presidential candidate. And you appear to agree with my secondary point: racism tends to be expressed more openly in Michigan than in Seattle.

 

Michigan. Land of racial bliss. NOT. North. More "enlightened" than south. NOT.

 

Man, you're thick-headed as to the point and thin-skinned concerning racial politics...

 

...or simply superficial.

 

I suppose you'd find it more comfortable in polite and white New Hampshire, too, where Democrats stated one thing in the primary exit polls, but their racism cast a different ballot.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You think I'm dense, DeChristo?

 

You agree with what I said: racism and racial tension are more openly visible in Michigan but Seattle is in reality just as segregated as Detroit. You slam me for a warped view of the entire world because I remember Wallace winning the state in 1968 while in fact he simply won the Democratic primary there in 1972. Your only beef is that you think I must promote or prefer unacknowledged racism to good old fashioned KKK style honesty (or something like that)* and you've been getting all aggro and calling me names for ten posts. If I'm dense, what are you? Pointlessly caustic?

 

Its a lot more fun, in my opinion, to talk about issues than to slam just to slam. Have a nice day.

 

 

 

 

* KKK in Ann Arbor in 1996

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah, you're correct - my tone may have been unnecessarily aggressive. I simply tire of the routinely erroneous assertions and hyperbole in your posts, which contributes to the idea that you're "dense".

 

So, you've moved to stating as "fact" that Wallace won the Democratic primary. At this time, I'm not going to trouble with looking it up, but I doubt this - your "fact" - as well. Wallace ran on the American Independent Party ticket. In the general election, the State went to the Democratic candidate, Hubert Humphrey. Your statement does not make sense nor square with these elements.

 

It's obvious you have few skills, constructive experience, or sensibility with concern to issues of Race - which, is probably why you jump so readily to the hyperbolic (again), in this case, the KKK...in Ann Arbor, no less: easily, one of the most liberally-minded (and governed) cities in our Country.

 

It's disconcerting to find someone so unwilling to examine their own judgments and misconceptions - in this case, concerning Race.

 

Examine this statement:

Maybe it is different in the UP, where there really aren't any black people, are there?

Setting aside the ludicrousness of associating the Upper Peninsula culture which is similar to that of western Ontario, northern Minnesota, and northern Wisconsin, with southern Michigan, you imply a remedy for racial tension is separation. Or, as in your personal anecdotes, to ignore politely. You've plopped yourself between the sheets with strange bedfellows.

 

How ironic to find this acceptance of unresolved personal conflict (whether internal or overt) and abstinence from the pursuit of understanding, in one whose persona promotes, regularly, the "meeting of the minds".

 

I'm not slamming you "just to slam". You, as all of us, earn a slamming on a regular basis for foisted inaccurate statements and the appearance of sentiments at odds with an identity built online, accumulatively. This time, I, uncharacteristically, was the one who took the time.

 

If you can't have an ice day, I hope you have a nice day.

 

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

DeChristo, I grew up in Ann Arbor. I am well aware of the fact that it is a liberal city. My father was a professor there, and I was very proud of the fact that he marched with Martin Luther King in Selma. I was surprised when I typed "KKK Michigan" in google and a KKK demonstration in Ann Arbor was one of the first things that came up. (I thought to search this because I knew kids growing up who were very proud of the fact that the grand dragon lived in Mason County or some such place. You may debunk that memory and maybe it was only a local Klan hero or something - I don't know.) Anyway, Google revealed that Ann Arbor item and all kinds of other articles about a long history of KKK activity throughout southern Michigan. I used to vacation up north, too, and I am well aware of the different culture there. Oh, and by the way: here's the site where I found that Wallace had won that primary: WIkipedia My memory was correct that he had won an election in that period, though I apologize profusely that I insulted you by saying it was a national vote.

 

My original argument was in no way hyperpole. Try using google some time. Search "racial tension Michigan" and search "racial tension Seattle." Try "Klu Klux Klan Michigan" and "Klu Klux Klan Seattle." See what comes up. I visit Michigan once in a while and I don't think the web is misleading on this point.

 

Oh: and by the way: several days a month I work in an office where "access to justice" is part of our mission and half our service population are people of color. I may not be omniscient but I think I know a little bit about the sensitivities involved. I do, however, believe in saying what I think. And I think southern Michigan is more racist and racism is more visible there than in Seattle. NOwhere did I say or imply that a remedy to racism is to hide or ignore it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I agree wit ya, DC concerning ethnocentrism (a few posts up). Harvard's Implicit Association Test suggests that all of us have a subconscious racial bias.

 

Oddly enough, it may work in Obama's favor.

 

BTW, McCain supporters...what does McCain propose to upgrade our infrastructure and how does he propose to fund it?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

STP, I don't know about the Harvard Implicit Association Test but I am sure that we all do have a racial bias. Hell: I go to a 99% white church where we talk about diversity at least once a month. There goes my insensitivity that DeChristo pointed out once again.

 

It'd probably be equally insensitive to point out that here in Seattle we elected an African American mayor in a big city that is overwhelmingly white (a first in the U.S., perhaps?). And I don't think that race was an issue in the election. I liked Mayor Rice because he made advertisements for KCMU, saying he liked Gas Huffer and Catt Butt. He apparently recognized a great radio station for what it was, and had fun celebrating that fact.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

STP, I don't know about the Harvard Implicit Association Test but I am sure that we all do have a racial bias. Hell: I go to a 99% white church where we talk about diversity at least once a month. There goes my insensitivity that DeChristo pointed out once again.

 

 

"Sensibility", my man.

 

to wit: once a month talks about diversity with a 99%-white church group.

 

you ought to lead a mission trip to Michigan.

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




×
×
  • Create New...